![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
(download
this page in PDF format)
|
| Indicator |
State of Michigan |
Marquette County |
Alger County |
| Births to Teenage Mothers |
9.6% |
7.7% |
11.8% |
| Students with Free/Reduced Lunch |
32.9% |
29.5% |
33.7% |
| Children Receiving Food Stamps |
12.3% |
7.5% |
9.8% |
| Michigan Merit Scholars |
39.4% |
53.3% |
56.0% |
| Poverty Rate |
9.9% |
10.9%* |
10.3%** |
| % Between 5-17 | 19.3% |
16.3%* |
15.9%** |
| Median Household Income |
$44,667 |
$35,548* |
$35,892** |
| Uninsured < 18 |
8.4% |
11.7% |
8.6% |
Sources: www.kidscount.org; http://www.mpca.net/healthpolicy/profiles.htm;
http://midata.msu.edu/index02.asp; http://www.mcgi.state.mi.us/mischoolinfo/
Thriving Indicators and Risk Behaviors: Marquette
and Alger County Youth
Concurrent with the survey of 40 Developmental Assets, questions were
asked of youth participants regarding their risk behaviors (e.g., substance
abuse; violence; truancy) and the extent to which they exhibit thriving
indicators (e.g., school success; helping others; leadership). As indicated
in Figures 5, 6, 7 and 8 the greater the number of assets, the greater
the number of thriving indicators and lower the number of risk behaviors.
(Figures 5 – 8 should be interpreted with great care, especially when
attempting to make comparisons between the 6th Grade data and the 8th,
10th and 12th Grade data. Note specifically that the number of “Thriving”
and “Risk” behaviors that are possible differ between these data sources.)
Figure 5: Average # of 7 Thriving Indicators by Asset Level, 6th Grade
Figure 6: Average # of 8 Thriving Indicators by Asset Level, 8th-12th Grade
Figure 7: Average # of 6 Risk-Taking Behaviors by Asset Level, 6th Grade
Figure 8: Average # of 24 Risk-Taking Behaviors by Asset Level, 8th-12th Grades
![]()
Developmental Assets: A Profile
of Marquette and Alger County Youth
Every child is unique and must be assessed in light of the family, school
and social context within which they live and develop over time. Nevertheless,
all need communities that support their development in effect ways (external
assets), allowing them to attain the tools (internal assets) necessary
to be productive and contributing members of society. As noted earlier,
the 40 Developmental Assets as formulated by the Search Institute include
20 External Assets (community-level) and 20 Internal Assets (individual-level).
The 40 Assets address four asset categories that focus on external structures,
relationships and activities (Support, Empowerment, Boundaries and Expectations,
Constructive Use of Time) and four categories that reflect internal values,
skills and beliefs (Commitment to Learning, Positive Values, Social Competencies,
Positive Identity). Hence, these assets focus on social rather than physical
developmental assets. Moreover, they provide an opportunity to look at
how our communities are progressing over nearly a decade of biennial surveys.
The biennial survey of 8th, 10th and 12th graders in Marquette County
(1997, 2000, 2002, and 2004 and the additional survey of 6th graders in
October, 2004, are the basis for the information included in this section
of the report (see xxxx for the full reports). The discussion of the results
will be organized around the four external and four internal categories
noted above. In addition, attention will be focused on the newly released
2004 data for 8th, 10th and 12th graders; obvious trending in the 8th,
10th and 12th grade data from 1997-2004; and on differences between the
6th grade data and the 8th, 10th and 12th grade data. The findings presented
in this section are intended to provide a general overview of the State
of the Youth to guide understanding and possible programming and intervention.
In many instances it will be important for readers to refer to the full
data report in order to understand the interpretation of specific concepts
and the survey questions from which they are derived.
External Assets: 2004: 8th, 10th and 12th Grades
The external/community-level assets provide the context within which youth
are able to build and mold individual assets. Hence, it is important for
families, schools and communities to carefully consider these findings
and the possibilities for modification and intervention.
External Assets: 1997-2004 Trends: 8th, 10th
and 12th Grades
The cross-sectional nature of these data limit the extent to which specific
conclusions can be made regarding changes over time. Nevertheless, where
trends reflect a 5% or greater change over the period 1997-2004, it is
instructive to note and give further consideration.
External Assets: 2004: Comparing 6th Grade
to 8th, 10th and 12th Grades
The comparison of the 6th grade data to that of the older youth must be
understood in the context of developmental stages. As noted earlier, 6th
graders are in the later stages of childhood while 8th, 10th and 12th
graders are adolescents developing toward the transition to adulthood.
Hence, the findings noted here should be understood in this context .
. . rather than as inherently problematic. Nevertheless, in some cases,
the findings may provide guidance for possible intervention strategies
designed to retain specific assets as youth transition from late childhood
to adolescence. Overall, total assets are higher among 6th graders (25.9)
than among the older youth (18.1) (refer to Figure 1).
Internal Assets: 2004: 8th, 10th and 12th
Grades
Internal assets are individual-level factors that generally reflect the
respondent’s assessment of themselves within the broader social context
within which they are situated.
Internal Assets: 1997 – 2004 Trend: 8th, 10th
and 12th Grades
The cross-sectional nature of these data limit the extent to which specific
conclusions can be made regarding changes over time. Nevertheless, where
trends reflect a 5% or greater change over the period 1997-2004, it is
instructive to note and give further consideration.
Internal Assets: 2004: Comparing 6th Grade
to 8th, 10th and 12th Grades
The comparison of the 6th grade data to that of the older youth must be
understood in the context of developmental stages. In general, 6th graders
are in the later stages of childhood while 8th, 10th and 12th graders
are adolescents developing toward the transition to adulthood. Hence,
the findings noted here should be understood in this context . . . rather
than as inherently problematic. Nevertheless, in some cases, the findings
may provide guidance for possible intervention strategies designed to
retain specific assets as youth transition from late childhood to adolescence.
Changing Behaviors & Developing Assets
In many respects, the 2005-2006 State of the Youth Report reinforces the
importance of the six priority areas previously identified by the Great
Lakes Center for Youth Development (see 2004 SOY Report) as essential
for building community capabilities and individual youth assets that will
foster healthy development in adolescence and a positive transition to
a productive adult life.
As indicated in the 2005 Youth Asset Report, there are many
ways in which individual parents, teachers, adult role models and others
can adopt behaviors that are likely to build and reinforce assets in youth
that will influence their healthy development.
In this section of the SOY Report we provide ideas and resources specific
to each of the six priority areas. Within each area we differentiate by
(1) community/school/family (external) and (2) youth (internal) strategies
for asset enhancement. It should be noted throughout, however, that many
of the most effective programs include both levels of development and
cross-cut two or more of the six priority areas. Moreover, the local issues
of concern (i.e., career pathways, substance abuse, and exercise) assessed
in the complementary “Sidebar Survey” (refer to www.soyreport.org/sidebar
for a full report) may also be addressed by types of programs addressed
in this section of the State of the Youth Report.
Maintaining Good Health
The World Health Organization defines health as “a state of complete physical,
mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or
infirmity” (http://www.who.int/about/definition/en/). Hence, it is appropriate
to view the healthy development of youth in the broadest possible sense.
Moreover, health issues among youth ranging from obesity to depression
have clearly become a national issue in recent years. The following examples
include programs that address external and internal aspects of maintaining
good health.
Community/School/Family: The Coordinated School Health
Program, sponsored by the National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention
and Health Promotion, focuses on eight interacting components to address
the nation’s most serious health and social problems (http://www.cdc.gov/HealthyYouth/CSHP/index.htm).
Families, health care workers, the media, religious organizations, community
organizations that serve youth, and young people themselves work together
to maintain the well-being of young people. This is one of many programs
designed under the auspices of the National Initiative to Improve
Adolescent Health by the Year 2010, which supports states and local
agencies, in part, by providing a range of practical resources focused
on strategic action to improve the health of adolescents and young adults
at the community level. Improving the Health of Adolescents &
Young Adults: A Guide for States and Communities (http://www.cdc.gov/HealthyYouth/NationalInitiative/order/index.htm)
is designed to help guide state and local agencies and organizations through
public health processes that address important adolescent health and safety
issues.
Youth: “My Health to Better Living: The 4-H Health Challenge”
is a Michigan 4-H Development Program designed to increase the number
of youth (5 to 12 years old) practicing healthy habits such as: choosing
not to use tobacco products, practicing sun safety, eating healthier and
being more physically active. The programs goals include learning health
behaviors as well as developing positive values such as responsibility
and restraint, positive identity and self-confidence, and competencies
to make healthy lifestyle choices. These latter attributes are similar
to those identified as “internal assets” in this report. Additional Information
can be found at: http://web1.msue.msu.edu/cyf/youth/health/index.html.
Decreasing Risk-Taking Behaviors
Risk-taking behaviors range from sexual experimentation to substance abuse.
As is often the case, the most successful programs address issues from
multiple perspectives. In addition, underlying “internal assets” such
as self-esteem and body image are recognized as important indicators of
risk behaviors.
Community/School/Family: School-based prevention programs
have had positive short term effects (typically declining in 1-4 years)
on smoking behavior and tobacco-related attitudes among middle school
students. Programs that focus on social influences (i.e. media, peer,
family) and teach refusal skills, however, tend to be the most effective.
School-based programs are further enhanced when they are included in broad
based community efforts in which parents, mass media, and community organizations
are involved, and in which the social policy or social environment as
well as individual knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors are targeted for
change. Guidelines issued by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC) (http://www.cdc.gov/) include:
(1) instruction should provide information on the social influences of
and peer norms regarding tobacco use in addition to information on the
short and long term physiologic consequences of smoking; (2) program-specific
training for teachers should be provided; and (3) schools should develop
and enforce tobacco free policies, to make sure programs are implemented
in a setting with broad policy support.
Youth: Advocates for Youth (http://www.advocatesforyouth.org/about/index.htm)
“is dedicated to creating programs and advocating for policies that help
young people make informed and responsible decisions about their reproductive
and sexual health.” In addition to information and programming about safer
sex, HIV, sexual assault and other important topics, emphases include
the recognition of the impact that body image has on youth’s lives. 15
Ways to Create a Body-Positive World helps to inform children and
youth of all ages about the importance of body image and how it can be
addressed in today’s world (http://www.advocatesforyouth.org/youth/health/bodyimage/bodypositive.htm).
Increasing Mentoring and Community Identity
Youth must be given both the tools to contribute to their community effectively
as well as the opportunity. Ensuring youth involvement – on community
boards, for example – and mentoring opportunities for community youth
can invigorate a town or city and provide new ideas and opportunities.
Community/School/Family: The Innovation Center for Community
and Youth Development (http://www.theinnovationcenter.org/a_mission.shtml)
views it’s mission accomplished – in part - when youth “are viewed as
valued resources and partners in every community, and they respond to
their respected status by devoting their tremendous energy and focus to
the pursuit of social and economic justice.” The At the Table Resource
Catalog provides information on eight organizations that help to
ensure meaningful youth involvement in leadership and services in communities
of all types and sizes (http://www.theinnovationcenter.org/pdfs/At_the_Table_Catalog.pdf).
Youth: The National Youth Mentoring Center (http://www.nwrel.org/mentoring/foundations.html)
has recently made available Foundations of Successful Youth Mentoring:
A Guidebook for Program Development (http://www.nwrel.org/mentoring/pdf/foundations.pdf)
to help guide communities in developing strong mentoring relationship
utilizing a variety of community-based models. In addition, the National
Youth Leadership Council (http://www.nylc.org/aboutus.cfm)
has adopted a service learning model designed to engage students in meaningful
service to their schools and communities. Through the provision of technical
assistance, conferences, workshops and networking that emphasize critical
thinking, problem-solving and the development of leadership skills, students
are given the tools to address real issues and value the contributions
and talents of people of all ages. Mentor Michigan (http://www.michigan.gov/mentormichigan),
initiated by Governor Granholm and her husband, similarly works to support
and enhance mentoring programs throughout the State of Michigan.
Improving Youth’s School Experience
For most children and adolescents, school is a “home away from home.”
Hence, as indicated by Developmental Assets, attachment, expectations,
boundaries and family involvement are critical elements that shape the
school experience. These issues are especially important because of the
connection between school experiences and the adjustment to young adulthood.
Moreover, the National Institute for Child Health and Human Development
(among others), has shown that strong school and family ties help to protect
teens from risk behaviors such as violence, drugs, suicide and early sex
(http://www.nichd.nih.gov/about/cpr/dbs/pubs/ti8.pdf).
Community/School/Family: The National Gardening Association
(http://assoc.garden.org/about)
is a leading national provider of K-12, plant-based educational materials.
School-based gardening programs provide a unique opportunity to help children
gain knowledge in science, literacy, social studies, nutrition, the environment,
and personal skill areas such as leadership, problem-solving, and team
building. In the U.P., Clear Lake Education Center (http://www.clearlakeinfo.org/)
adds an important element to the school experience by providing “an opportunity
for people of all ages to connect to the natural world through integrated
educational and recreational programs.”
Youth: The Macarthur Youth Commitment Network (http://www.macroc.nsw.gov.au/Content/templates/projects_detail.asp?articleid=22&zoneid=2)
in Australia focuses on young people “at risk” of leaving school early.
This emphasis is important because early leavers face long term disadvantages
such as unemployment, lower incomes and other risks to their wellbeing,
which in turn affect the communities in which they live. A just released
report by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention titled Healthy
Youth: An Investment in our Nation’s Future (http://www.macroc.nsw.gov.au/Content/templates/projects_detail.asp?articleid=22&zoneid=2)
reinforces the especially important role of schools in teaching healthy
behaviors and reducing harmful risk behaviors.
Strengthening Family Support and Involvement
Parents and family members are important sources of support, learning
and modeling. In an age when family separation, economic factors and other
strains on family life influence family support, it is increasingly important
to foster regular quality involvement by parents in the lives of children
and youth.
Community/School/Family: The Administration for Child
and Families, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, provides
information and funds projects intended to support families and children.
In particular, a recent report, A Childhood for Every Child (http://www.acf.hhs.gov/publications/acf_brochure/a_childhood.html)
provides a range of information on strengthening families, empowering
communities, and positive youth development. Similarly, The Center
for Family Involvement in Schools “provides equity-focused professional
development programs and resources that strengthen family-school-community
partnerships and encourage and support the academic, intellectual and
social development of all children” (http://www.rci.rutgers.edu/~cfis/).
Gladstone Area Schools recently adopted a “turn off the tv and video game”
campaign designed to foster family and student interaction by encouraging
involvement in other activities.
Youth: According to the National Service Learning
Clearinghouse (http://www.servicelearning.org/resources/quick_guides/family_k-12/)
research has demonstrated that strong family involvement has numerous
benefits for children and youth, including higher grades and test scores,
better school attendance, greater completion of homework, demonstration
of more positive attitudes and behavior, and higher graduation rates.
In addition, when parents maintain strong relationships with their children’s
schools, the parents develop a greater appreciation of their role in their
children’s education, an improved sense of self worth, stronger social
networks, and a greater understanding about their schools and teaching
and learning activities in general. Service-learning programs can benefit
parents by providing them with unique ways of communicating with and understanding
their children while also developing their skills as leaders and advocates
in their schools and communities.”
Enhancing Positive Identity and Social Competency
A positive identity and social competency among children and youth are
critical because of their links to school failure, risk-taking behaviors
and other less than ideal outcomes. This is particularly important in
the current context because some research indicates that self esteem declines
for most students the longer they are in school.
Community/School/Family: Todd McKinney, a Comedy Magician
and Magical Motivator, has developed shows that address topics such as
reading, substance abuse, bullying and self-esteem (http://magicmaninfo.com/page809.html).
The Public Broadcasting System (http://www.pbs.org/wholechild/parents/getting.html)
identifies four components to the development of social competence that
parents should be aware of: (1) modeling behavior; (2) sharing from the
heart; (3) fairness; and (4) cooperation versus competition.
Youth: The Child Health Institute (http://www.childdevelopmentinfo.com/parenting/self_esteem.shtml)
makes a number of suggestions for how parents can enhance self-esteem
in their children. As with other priority areas, the development of good
self-esteem is predicated on the development of other skills such as good
communication, good parenting, and the ability to recognize developmental
changes over time.
Summary
In most respects children and youth in Marquette and Alger Counties are
similar to their peers throughout the United States. This focus on Developmental
Assets has, however, provided a means to identify areas of both strength
and weakness, and too explore possible resources that may help to improve
both community- and individual-level assets that will enhance well-being
at all levels. The healthy development of youth in the Upper Peninsula
will be best affected by comprehensive programming that recognizes the
unique characteristics of individual communities while drawing on the
substantial worldwide resources for intervention and change.